An 88-year-old survivor of the condo collapse in Surfside, Florida, was carried to safety by her neighbors

"They push me out and we got into water," said Esther Gorfinkel, who credits her neighbors for helping her escape as the building fell to the ground. "And then they push me, push me and push me. There was a lot of debris and we saw a hole that you can see outside. They push me. They pick me up. I saw the sky. I knew I will be safe."

           

https://www.facebook.com/cnn/posts/10162113676946509

What wonderful neighbors she has, to help her make it out alive. I can’t imagine being 88 years old, and losing everything so suddenly, including friends. It seems trivial, but I hope there is some way to eventually retrieve something she cherishes, even if it’s one photo album. She deserves it. I know the rescue workers, as they’re looking for people, have been trying to set aside any important personal items they find for the families, when it’s feasible to do it. There was a birthday card full of photos that was found in the rubble, which ended up belonging to a woman who was listed among the missing. It was given to her adult son, and it meant everything to him just to have that. ️


I am living a complete life as a married woman since I regained my man one year back because of your work Mama Lisa. My relationships were characterized by rejections and heartbreaking many times I was left by men with no clear reasons some could just disappear and cut off communications and I thought it was part of life but when Thapelo left me I couldn't handle it was too much for me I cried a lot till I discovered I needed to do something about my relationship. although I contacted many people for help I did a lot of things hoping to see good results but none delivered their promises. When I saw the article about Mama Lisa I gave her a try as I was desperatel for help and this time she explained to me that this was a generational curse that needed to be cleansed so that my life could be set free once again. Mama Lisa told me that my man loves me and we had a future with him but the factors leading him to leave me were both a generational curse and that someone had put a spell on her, I sent her money for the things she needed to do my work. We conducted special prayers over the phone as Mama Lisa instructed me for two consecutive days and surprisingly my man came back within 48 hours all matters were resolved we are now married for two years and we hope for the best we are so happy I have seen a lot of changes in my whole life even at work everyone respects me this is why I leave your number here for everyone who wants your help to contact you for such unfinished work. CALL OR WHATS-APP Mama Lisa +27794327901


Visual Forensics deepen questions about role of pool deck in condo collapse This is a caption

Experts analyze

By Wash Post Reporting

A resident told The Post that minutes before Champlain Towers South in Surfside came down, she noticed that a section of the pool deck and a street-level parking area had collapsed into the parking garage below. The husband of another resident has said that his wife, who has not been seen since the disaster, made a similar observation in a telephone call shortly before the collapse.

An engineer in 2018 found “major structural damage” in the pool deck area caused by what he said was a flaw that limited water drainage. At least 12 people were killed and 149 remain unaccounted for following a type of disaster that is unheard of in the United States.

The investigation into the collapse last Thursday is likely to take many months and may find no single definitive cause. Experts urged caution and some structural engineers said they doubted that a collapse in the deck slab would have jeopardized the beachside building’s overall integrity. But Allyn E. Kilsheimer, a veteran engineer hired by Surfside to investigate the collapse, told The Post that such a failure could have set off a wider catastrophe.

“There is a possibility that part of the pool [area] came down first and then dragged the middle of the building with it, and that made that collapse,” said Kilsheimer, who had previously voiced skepticism about the significance of the damage noted in the engineer’s report. “And then once the middle of the building collapsed, number two, then the rest of the building didn’t know how to stand up and it fell down also, number three.”

A resident told The Washington Post that part of the pool deck and the surface-level parking lot collapsed before the building.

Such a catastrophe is extraordinary for a 40-year-old building even if a range of imaginable failures had occurred, the experts said. The building collapse is as shocking “to the public in general … as it is to the engineering community,” said Joe DiPompeo, the president of the Structural Engineering Institute of the American Society of Civil Engineers. “There’s got to be a very specific sequence of events that somehow evaded all the fail-safes in the code and everything else.”

Sara Nir, a resident, told The Post that shortly before 1 a.m., she noticed loud “knocking” noises that she assumed were caused by construction work. Around 1:14 a.m., she heard a noise that she thought sounded like a wall crashing down, and she left her ground-level apartment to complain to a security guard in the lobby.

She estimated that about a minute later, while she was in the lobby, she heard a very large boom and saw that part of the surface-level parking area — and part of the pool deck — had collapsed into the underground parking garage. She and the two of her children who were home at the time then ran from the building.
Nir’s son called 911 at 1:19 a.m., he said, a time that he said he confirmed by checking the time stamp on his phone. About a minute later, a dispatcher with Miami-Dade County Fire and Rescue called for an engine to respond to an alarm at the building, audio shows.
According to additional EMS audio, the building collapsed between 1:24 and 1:25 a.m. while Engine 76 was en route.
Nir was previously interviewed by COLlive, an independently run Orthodox Jewish news service.
The Champlain complex was a steel-reinforced concrete structure with 136 apartments spread across 12 stories plus a penthouse. The only public video footage of the building collapse appears to be a recording of surveillance footage captured by a camera on a neighboring property. It has no time stamp. Some experts who reviewed the footage found it significant that the exterior of the upper floors appeared intact as the building began to fall.
“You can see the failure came from the bottom,” said Kit Miyamoto, a veteran structural engineer and the chairman of the California seismic safety commission.
The center facade's ability to maintain its integrity as the building begins to fall indicates a structural failure at the base or lower levels of the building, some experts said.
The rest of the middle section appeared to fold into itself and drop straight down.
Miyamoto described the middle section as “vertically imploding,” indicating that columns toward the bottom must have been “compromised.” Several other experts said that the video pointed to columns in this area having given way, setting off a cascade of damage.
The experts said that the columns may either have suffered “axial failure,” meaning that they suffered too much stress from compression, or punching shear failure, when a concrete slab fails under pressure at the point that it connects to the column and falls. The column effectively “punches” through the slab. This can cause a succession of collapses as weight accumulates from above, the experts said.
While experts The Post spoke to were divided over the role of the columns in the collapse, several observed that visible dents such as this one were probably where the columns used to be connected to the concrete slabs that make up the flooring of each level.
Scott Homrich, the president of the National Demolition Association, said that while there was no sign that the Surfside collapse was caused deliberately, the sequence of events resembled that seen in many controlled demolitions....
https://www.washingtonpos...condo-collapse/




+